Oscar: Big Studios Dominate the Awards–When and How?

For two decades, the Academy was controlled by the big studios, with nominations dominated by a few powerful cliques within the studios. “The trick,” as Capra observed, “was to get nominated by the clique of major studio directors who had achieved membership–and those Brahmins were not about to doff their caps to the “untouchables” of Poverty Row,” as the small studios were then labeled. “Making good pictures was not enough,” Capra quickly realized. “I would have to gain status with big name directors to get them to nominate me.”

Oscar: MGM’s Dominance of the Awards

During Louis B. Mayer's reign, MGM received more than its fair share of nominations and awards. In the first decade, MGM earned a total of 153 nominations and 33 awards, a record surpassing that of other studios. Paramount ranked a distant second, with 102 nominations and 18 awards, followed by Warner, with 71 nominations and 15 awards. Fox and Columbia featured poorly, the former with 54 nominations and 13 awards, the latter with 43 nominations and 10 awards.

Oscar Politics: Campaigns–New Tools, New Methods

Screenwriter William Goldman has observed that if videocassettes had existed before, movies that had been overlooked would have been honored. Peckinpah's Ride the High Country, Scorsese's Mean Streets, and Lawrence Kasdan's Body Heat would have likely garnered Best Director and acting nominations, if not Best Picture.

Oscar Politics: Campaigns–Miramax (“Shakespeare in Love”) Vs. DreamWorks (“Saving Private Ryan”)

“American Beauty”'s Best Picture represented, as Dana Harris wrote in Variety, a coming-of-age for DreamWorks, an upstart studio that began operation in 1994. The film's five Oscars, including Best Director and Actor, were a sweet victory after the disappointment the company had faced the year prior, when Saving Private Ryan earned Best Director for Spielberg but lost Best Picture to Miramax's Shakespeare in Love.

Oscar Actors: Cher

Advertising ensures that a movie will not be accidentally overlooked, which was crucial to Yentl, since it divided critics and opened to lukewarm reviews–it received five nominations. It's hard to tell whether Silkwood's five nominations were attributable to the ad campaign. Meryl Streep would have been nominated for Best Actress and Mike Nichols for Best Director without the campaign–anything with Streep gets extra attention. But Cher, nominated for supporting award, certainly benefited from the campaign.